R. v. Skye View Farms et al., 2021 PESC 27 (CanLII)

This case was heard in the Supreme Court of Prince Edward Island.

Dead fish were reported in the Clyde River and upon investigation, Fisheries Officers found the cause to be agricultural runoff containing pesticides. Skye View Farms Ltd. and its directors were accused of unlawfully depositing pesticides from their potato farm into the Clyde River and charged pursuant to s. 36(3) of the Fisheries Act.

During trial, Skye View Farms argued that the authorities had conducted an illegal search of the land without a warrant, violating their s. 8 Charter rights protecting against unreasonable search and seizure. The trial judge agreed that there was a Charter breach and excluded the evidence obtained from the search. As a result, the prosecution was unable to prove essential elements of the charges, leading to a finding of not guilty.

The Crown then appealed, arguing that the trial court made two mistakes. First, by assessing a violation of rights under s. 8 of the Charter and, by improperly interpreting and applying the Charter to exclude evidence, pursuant to s. 24(2).

Trial courts typically receive deference in appellate courts, because they are in the best position to assess the evidence presented during trial. Here the trial court did performed an appropriate analysis of the privacy interests at stake and made a decision based on the evidence available. Therefore, there was no reason for the Supreme Court to overturn that decision.

This appeal was dismissed on both grounds, upholding the trial judge's decision to exclude the evidence obtained from the warrantless search and the acquittal of the accused.

View the Decision on CanLII: 2021 PESC 27 (CanLII) | R. v. Skye View Farms et al. | CanLII

Disclaimer: 
Case briefs in our Resource Library are drafted by law students who work or volunteer with East Coast Environmental Law, and East Coast Environmental Law does not guarantee their fullness or accuracy. Library users should not rely on case briefs as comprehensive accounts of the issues, facts, reasoning, or outcomes at stake in any given case.  
 
If you require more detailed information about a court decision or legal issue, please consider using our Environmental Law Inquiry Service to request information from our staff. 

Previous
Previous

Ecology Action Centre v Canada (Environment and Climate Change), 2021 FC 1367  

Next
Next

PEI Energy Corporation (Re), 2020 CanLII 125986 (PE IRAC)